The Warlocks Den - WoW Warlock DiscussionsThe Warlocks Den - WoW Warlock Discussions



Please Register to Remove these Ads

The Warlocks Den - WoW Warlock Discussions » Discussion Forums » Spells, Talents and DPS Discussion » Raiding Builds » Warlock Threat

Raiding Builds A special place dedicated to the current raiding build threads.

Reply
Old September 04, 2009, 03:45 PM   #81 (permalink)

Character Info
Jaystone
80 Human Warlock
Quel'dorei US PvE
Guild: Sanctified Vengeance
Talent Spec: 0/18/53
Re: Warlock Threat

I believe we must be responsible for our own actions. There are times when tanks aren't geared appropriately but since we are working together in a group we must do what is necessary to ensure survival. If that means gimping DPS, sobeit. I agree if you compare threat per dps/damage done to other classes warlocks, have it the worst.

"Check my armory, I'm top dps in my guild. Afterwards check my MT. If any of you is capable on overaggroing him, and out dpssing me, I'll give ya a medal."
Benituccio, I hope you have alot of medals!
evilsrh is offline   Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links

Old September 04, 2009, 03:57 PM   #82 (permalink)

Character Info
Nocturnus
80 Warlock
EU-Kazzak PvP
Guild: <Absolute>
Profile: Blizzard Armory

3.2 Re: Warlock Threat

Quote:
Originally Posted by evilsrh View Post
I believe we must be responsible for our own actions. There are times when tanks aren't geared appropriately but since we are working together in a group we must do what is necessary to ensure survival. If that means gimping DPS, sobeit. I agree if you compare threat per dps/damage done to other classes warlocks, have it the worst.

"Check my armory, I'm top dps in my guild. Afterwards check my MT. If any of you is capable on overaggroing him, and out dpssing me, I'll give ya a medal."
Benituccio, I hope you have alot of medals!
I didn't mean to seem arrogant, afterall it's just a game. I'm just saying that if I can't overaggro my MT whilst SUSTAINING more than 7k dps on most nuke bosses, I know you can't do it either.

About warlocks having it the worst, no mate no, mages have it much, much worse. Their aggro dump is utter crap and forces them to stop nuking for 3 seconds. If you're a capable and dedicated dpsser, you'll worry about wasting one GCD, let alone 3 seconds.

Just have a quick look at this simple combat log, the dps you see there is sustained, yet never had to shatter once:

World of Logs - Real Time Raid Analysis

Last edited by noctywocty; September 04, 2009 at 04:03 PM..
noctywocty is offline   Reply With Quote
Old September 04, 2009, 05:08 PM   #83 (permalink)

Character Info
Helixir
80 Human Warlock
Suramar US PvE
Guild: FEG
Profile: WoW Rankings
Talent Spec: 0/41/30
3.2 Re: Warlock Threat

Quote:
Originally Posted by noctywocty View Post
About warlocks having it the worst, no mate no, mages have it much, much worse. Their aggro dump is utter crap and forces them to stop nuking for 3 seconds.
I don't expect consensus on that point, but my experience has been otherwise. My first character is a mage and I've been gearing him up again lately. A mage has both mirror images and invis to be proactive, and blink/iceblock for emergencies. Put that together with lower threat per damage generation, and it's just easier. The lock dies more often.

Those that sneer at that statement are fortunate. I have, playing a warlock, run with tanks where their keeping up with my threat was not a problem, but it's been the exception. The reverse has been true of the mage, and the damage is comparable.
Bap10c4 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old September 04, 2009, 05:34 PM   #84 (permalink)

Character Info
Nocturnus
80 Warlock
EU-Kazzak PvP
Guild: <Absolute>
Profile: Blizzard Armory

3.2 Re: Warlock Threat

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bap10c4 View Post
I don't expect consensus on that point, but my experience has been otherwise. My first character is a mage and I've been gearing him up again lately. A mage has both mirror images and invis to be proactive, and blink/iceblock for emergencies. Put that together with lower threat per damage generation, and it's just easier. The lock dies more often.

Those that sneer at that statement are fortunate. I have, playing a warlock, run with tanks where their keeping up with my threat was not a problem, but it's been the exception. The reverse has been true of the mage, and the damage is comparable.
Iceblock and Blink can't be considered aggro reducing abilities man. If you do, you should consider Teleport for the Warlock as well, but that would sound silly wouldn't it? Granted, IB does give the tank more time to taunt the target off. I disagree completely with your statement that Warlocks die most. Warlocks are actually the cloth-class that mitigates most damage via SL and high stamina. Where a mage gets one shot (Freya hardmode pre nerfs) a Warlock survives.

Good tanks being an exception depends on who you take as a tank. For me a bad tank is an exception.

I think we should start discussing how to help our tanks get control of their class, rather than complaining about threat.

Warlocks are ,in almost all aspects of this game, fine.

Last edited by noctywocty; September 04, 2009 at 05:38 PM..
noctywocty is offline   Reply With Quote
Old September 05, 2009, 02:38 PM   #85 (permalink)

Character Info
Helixir
80 Human Warlock
Suramar US PvE
Guild: FEG
Profile: WoW Rankings
Talent Spec: 0/41/30
3.2 Re: Warlock Threat

Quote:
Originally Posted by noctywocty View Post
Iceblock and Blink can't be considered aggro reducing abilities man. If you do, you should consider Teleport for the Warlock as well, but that would sound silly wouldn't it? Granted, IB does give the tank more time to taunt the target off. I disagree completely with your statement that Warlocks die most. Warlocks are actually the cloth-class that mitigates most damage via SL and high stamina. Where a mage gets one shot (Freya hardmode pre nerfs) a Warlock survives.

Good tanks being an exception depends on who you take as a tank. For me a bad tank is an exception.

I think we should start discussing how to help our tanks get control of their class, rather than complaining about threat.

Warlocks are ,in almost all aspects of this game, fine.
Sorry man, but I beg to differ with you on the point of survivability. The main problem with threat is that it gets everyone killed. My personal experience indicates warlock has an issue with excessive threat generation, and few ways out when accidents do happen.
Bap10c4 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old September 05, 2009, 02:51 PM   #86 (permalink)

Character Info
Jenerena
80 Blood Elf Warlock
Executus Euro PvP
Guild: Deliverance
Profile: Blizzard Armory
Talent Spec: 0/13/58
3.2 Re: Warlock Threat

Quote:
Originally Posted by noctywocty View Post
Warlocks are ,in almost all aspects of this game, fine.
I agree with this. BUT i don't think it is always the tank's fault, unless he is actually under geared or not half-decent. But look at other classes, do they get aggro as well? If it's only you, then it's not the tank. I tend to be the one down from the tank in Omen because my damage output is on average a little higher than others. BUT i put out a large amount of damage and rarely have to stop anymore, i soulshatter below 50% so i don't get stuck, and i'm careful when i start. If you're doing everything right, yes maybe look at the tank, but i am unconvinced by warlocks who complain about it as there are plenty of other locks who don't.

Not taking aggro is a challenging thing, and a good skill to master.
Jenren22 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Today, 08:19 AM   #87 (permalink)

Character Info
Loech
80 Orc Warlock
Suramar US PvE
Guild: Into the Abyss

3.2 Re: Warlock Threat

Quote:
Originally Posted by noctywocty View Post
Iceblock and Blink can't be considered aggro reducing abilities man. If you do, you should consider Teleport for the Warlock as well, but that would sound silly wouldn't it? Granted, IB does give the tank more time to taunt the target off. I disagree completely with your statement that Warlocks die most. Warlocks are actually the cloth-class that mitigates most damage via SL and high stamina. Where a mage gets one shot (Freya hardmode pre nerfs) a Warlock survives.

Good tanks being an exception depends on who you take as a tank. For me a bad tank is an exception.

I think we should start discussing how to help our tanks get control of their class, rather than complaining about threat.

Warlocks are ,in almost all aspects of this game, fine.
Utter nonsense. So what if for YOU bad tanks are the exception. That is irrelevant. What you're saying is that with a great tank warlocks don't need to worry. Big deal. What we're saying is that with an average tank it's ONLY warlocks that need to worry. Mages have Mirror Image which gives them a period of grace for the tank to pick it up, they've got Iceblock which again keeps them alive till the tank picks it up and they've got a 100% agro dump from their Invis, compared to our 50%. If you look at arcane (current best mage spec) they don't even need to Invis, because they've got 40% threat reduction. Oh, and warlocks get 1 hit just as much as mages. I, for one, don't run around with soul link in my pve spec. Even if I did I'd likely still get 1 hit.

When starting a fight I see a lot of people with their threat bars up there, retadins, hunters, mages, along with the locks. By about 20 seconds into the fight the lock is always the top of that list, with the tank not too far ahead. Great, if you've got a tank that completely outgears you then you'll be fine. Otherwise the WARLOCKS have to worry. Not the mages, they don't care if the tank's bad, nor the rogues or huntards or anyone else. Just the locks. Well, with that much threat we must be doing a massive amount of damage right? We should just learn to manage our dps yeah? Nup. Our damage is nothing special, and if we just stopped dpsing all the time when it looked like we might catch the tank then we'd be out of the top 5 dps altogether. Threat is an issue for warlocks. If you don't think so well then you're

Oh, and we do NOT have one of the best agro dumps. All three of the other pure dps classes have better agro dumps. Mages, rogues and huntards all have 100% agro dumps, and I'd rather have any of them than lame arse soul shatter. Huntards have theirs on a 30 sec CD! Mages and rogues can survive a wipe with theirs! Not to mention that huntards can MD, rogues have ToT and mages have MI!
Sigoroth is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Today, 09:01 AM   #88 (permalink)

Character Info
lilsteele
80 Human Warlock
Terenas Euro PvE

3.2 Re: Warlock Threat

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sigoroth View Post
All this rage right after we got our threat reduction buffed just a few days ago


Btw, if you get one-shotted, learn to play. A dps should never pull off the tank, no matter how bad it is. When the boss moves because someone pulls off the tank, it can often wipe the raid, no matter how fast the tank is with taunt or whether the dps can iceblock/feign death or not.
lilsteele is online now   Reply With Quote
Old Today, 12:32 PM   #89 (permalink)

Character Info
Chula
80 Human Warlock
Shattrath Euro PvE
Guild: INSEPARABILIS
Talent Spec: 3/13/55
3.2 Re: Warlock Threat

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sigoroth View Post
...
Great, if you've got a tank that completely outgears you then you'll be fine. Otherwise the WARLOCKS have to worry. ...
What content are you talking about and what average ilvl of tank(s) and you?
My main's a feral tank, and I'm not thinking about me as world's most blessed player (well, sometimes^^). I'm putting out (with MD and ToT) some 7-8k tps through normal fights (toc 10/25) and have not heard any complains by any dps class, that they had to take a book and read some paragraphs let alone pages to not over aggro the tank. Considering 20% threat reduce by talents you'd have to run some 8.5k ++ dps to be on par with my main's threat. If you show me some dpser to run 8.5k, I show you someone who completely outgears me.^^
Main's guild is somewhere at the borderline of fun/casual/raid guild. Only hard part to deal with is heroism at the very start of phase 2 of boss 1 in toc, but that's where MD and ToT really shine.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bap10c4 View Post
...
Those that sneer at that statement are fortunate. I have, playing a warlock, run with tanks where their keeping up with my threat was not a problem, but it's been the exception. The reverse has been true of the mage, and the damage is comparable.
Your arsenal link shows 81 hit which makes me guess I caught you in 'farm heroics'-gear. Ok, let's talk about heroics (5 mens). They DO NOT matter. Tanks most prominent problem in heroics is getting rage, No Rage, No Threat! While level of heroic trash means to dpser, that they hit harder, it means to tanks, taht they get hit smoother while dodging even more, both not a good thing to gain rage. I try not to pug heroics, but sh*t happens and I sometimes join group led by undergeared tanks. I just tell them not to mind if I over aggro them and also tell healers to nively have an eye on tanking lock.^^ Healers like tanking locks in heroics, make it less boring for them.^^
Chula is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Tags
Threat, warlock

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:14 PM.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by vBSEO 3.3.0